Late at night, Zoe and Ethan share an almost-confession moment, caught between friendship and something more. What they can’t admit to each other, they finally confess in private — Zoe to Lily, Ethan to Bryan. And as their best friends read the messages, the sparks of their secret plan to bring them together begin to glow brighter.

That Saturday night, Lily couldn’t shake the feeling that the answer was already staring her in the face. And when Zoe mentioned the fountain again casually, between bites of cupcake, something clicked. A ridiculous, impossible something. The kind of something that could explain everything. Next, she just had to convince Bryan… and then figure out how to undo a magical wish without setting anything else on fire.

Lily and Bryan join forces to break the wish by rekindling the original flame. Can chaos undo magic? Let’s find out.

Zoe and Ethan’s behavior is starting to freak everyone out. Lily and Bryan meet up to compare notes, and what they discover changes everything.

Chapter 2: Cupcakes & Pecs

They wished to marry their best friends—then remembered who that really was.