Al-fatihah untuk arwah Saleem Iklim dan Pak Ngah. Tema konsert semalam was out of genre ke apa tah. Kiranya macam peserta kena nyanyi lagu yang bukan kebiasaan diorang lah. So below are my views solely based on what I hear, see and feel. Noted that I'm not a professional kritik so jangan kritik saya kerana mengkritik.
1) Forteen - Suci Dalam Debu (Iklim)
I don't know persembahan dorang macam awkward sikit most probably I'm listening through a phone but the arrangement pelik sikit kot? Plus it is not an easy song to sing but seriously I can't help to notice how awkward it is! Again one suara yang paling sedap and Amir suara paling tak sedap but kena kritik depan-depan macam tu sentap jugak lah rasa kot.
2) Dia Fadila - Dondang Dendang (Noraniza Idris)
Apo siap bagi tips pilih bilik hotel kan. Tapi I like her performance semalam awal-awal lah and I think best lah dia bawa lagu tu even irama Malaysia bukan makanan dia. Dah nama pun guru vokal and saya rasa kelemahan dia is dia punya nervousness sebab teknik nyanyian semua okay je rasanya. As I said earlier, persembahan dia awal-awal best tapi hujung-hujung tu macam suara penat. Even Ibu pun perasan dia nervous.
3) Billy Zulkarnain - Mahakarya Cinta (Faizal Tahir)
Kenapa eh semalam? Rasanya macam semua nyanyi tak ikut tempo? ke my phone punya stereo kuat music compared to vocal? Dah masuk persembahan ketiga pun I feel like they sang out of tempo. Lagu ni kalau Faizal nyanyi boleh meremang bulu roma and hampir menangis sebab feel dia tu but sorry Billy Zulkarnain performed semalam tak sampai. I don't know what went wrong but I just don't feel it.
4) Shafie - Yang Penting Happy (Jamal Mirdad)
He can really sing and suara dia memang sedap tapi persembahan semalam kurang sikit compared to kalau dia nyanyi lagu-lagu ballad kot. I think he can be the front-runner this season. Tak boleh nak komen banyak sebab rasanya persembahan dia okay je kot cuma tak berapa nak happening compared to Hetty nyanyi last week.
5) Elite - Ku Bahagia (Melly Goeslow)
As usual suara off lah tapi persembahan tip-top! Antara bertiga ni I think Azza suara boleh pergi sikit lah compared dengan yang lagi dua tu and obviously Sasha out terus. Lupa lirik pula kan they should know better kalau dah vocal bukan strength, make sure persembahan clean. Apa-apa pun I enjoyed their performance sangat-sangat and after yesterday I wish they last longer sebab nak tengok persembahan dorang je and betul lah Tok Ram cakap, suka tengok friendship dorang.
6) Maya - I Have Nothing (Whitney Houston)
Bergegar sikit kan starting tu and entah lah I think phone problem sangat ni sebab dengar Maya nyanyi pun macam tak ikut tempo. But weird enough time Elite nyanyi kena pula tempo. Nyanyian dia okay-okay lah cuma pronunciation dia tu buat kacau sikit kot lagipun lagu ni memang susah pun sebab Whitney Houston kot yang nyanyi. Feel tu hampir nak sampai tapi tak kesampaian sebab nervous kot. Apa-apa pun I think she can go far jugak lah dalam GV ni. Dah lah muka macam Che Ta!
7) Noryn Aziz - Kabut Serangkai Mawar (Zaiton Sameon)
Noryn ni bahagian feel lagu tu bagi dekat dia lah, memang on point and I wonder dia pernah berlakon tak? Vokal yesterday I think her best by far and compared to lagu trauma last week, semalam best lagi! One of my favorite for final I think or is it too early to say? And yang ni ikut tempo so I think my phone tak rosak after all. Rindu Kak Ton Sameon.
8) Zamani - This Love (Maroon 5)
Uhhhh cringe but honestly dia nampak macam Radhi OAG and I don't think this song suits his voice at all. He sounds like Adam's speaking voice and sebab tu his performance sedikit suram sebab lagu ni suara kalau mantap feel dia akan lebih lagi and akan rasa seronok but to me yesterday, feel tu tak berapa nak sampai and seronok lagu tu tak rasa and setuju dengan Tok Ram, Zamani needs more energy!
9) Farawahida - Lagu Rindu Merindu (Fauziah Idris)
Semalam memang sedap suara Farawahida! Lagu tu memang kena dengan vokal dia! Tapi kenapa entah persembahan tak rasa excited and ada vibe sedih? Is it because the music arrangement macam lain sikit ke lagu asal memang vibe sedih? Kalau ikut lirik memang sedih lah but rasanya lagu ni fun kot sebab beat dia macam laju-laju sikit.
10) Hetty Sarlene - Pawana (Search)
Suara Hetty ni soft so nyanyi lagu rock tu nampak cantik but she can sing lah. Walaupun ada attempt dia nak buat bunyi-bunyi rock tu macam tak kena but A+ for effort! Persembahan A+ juga tapi tu lah vokal kot off sikit.
11) Amelina - Segalanya Pasti (Aida Agil)
Please lah stop nyanyi atas platform boleh tak? Kak Long suara memang sedap lah and I think she sounds better nyanyi lagu-lagu macam ni instead of dangdut tu dengar suara satu tone je. Tak pernah dengar lagu ni before so tak dapat nak compare but personally I think Kak Long did justice to the song lah and other than Noryn, Amelina pun nyanyi feel on point!
Seperti biasa dibawah adalah kedudukan peserta mengikut pengamatan saya lah and dalam bracket is kedudukan dari juri and lagu untuk dorang nyanyi minggu depan dengan tema berduet:
1. Farawahida (2. Hati Ini Telah Dilukai - Ajai ft Kris Dayanti)
2. Noryn Aziz (3. Seksis - Anita Sarawak)
3. Amelina (1. Tak Pernah Hilang - Amelia ft Kaer)
4. Shafie ( 7. Ada Apa Dengan Cinta - Melly Goeslow ft Eric)
5. Dia Fadila (4. Tangisan Marheanis - Hattan ft Dia Fadila)
6. Maya (8. Bujang Senang - Wings)
7. Zamani (5. Ghazal Untuk Rabiah - Jamal Abdilah)
8. Hetty Sarlene (6. Aku Cinta Aku Rindu - Nurul ft Ajai)
9. Billy Zulkarnain (10. Hanya Memuji - Shanty ft Marcell)
10. Forteen (9. Seluruh Cinta - Siti Nurhaliza ft Cakra Khan)
11. Elite (Eliminated)
(I love you Elite and lepas ni boleh lah perform dekat events. Gonna miss you girsl! image by Astro Gempak)
P/S: Nak dengar lagu Dia Fadila sebab that is one of my favorite songs!